«On the days of ballets and pancakes...» Reflection of the Russian Imperial ballet in the personal diaries of Grand Duke Konstantin Nikolaevich

Abstract

The article represents the first publication, a source review and a comprehensive analysis of diary entries about ballet belonging to Grand Duke Konstantin Nikolaevich of Russia (1827–1892). His diaries, covering the period from 1837 to 1889, contain numerous statements about theatrical productions, Russian and European dancers and choreographers. The perspective of the paper is determined by the material chosen for study. The article includes the following sections: 1) The origins of the Grand Duke’s fascination with musical and choreographic art; 2) Taglioni’s ballets in the Grand Duke’s children’s diaries; 3) the Grand Duke dances “L’Écumeur de Mer” (with the chronograph “Adolphe Adam in St. Petersburg”, 1839/1840); 4) foreign impressions of the 1840s–1850s; 5) at the ballet with Alexander II of Russia (1860–1870s); 6) an unknown poem by Pyotr Vyazemsky in the Grand Duke’s diary (1874); 7) Marius Petipa and “Tsar Berendei” by Vasily Zhukovsky; 8) to the reconstruction of “Catarina, or La Fille du Bandit”: “Pas éspagnol” by Grand Duchess Alexandra Iosifovna of Russia (1870). In the conclusion preliminary results are summarized and further prospects for study of personal documents of the august ballet lovers of the 19th and early 20th centuries are outlined. The Appendix contains lists of ballets and ballet artists mentioned in the Grand Duke’s diaries, as well as a thematic selection of his notes on “Le Roi Candaule”, “Trilby”, “Camargo” and other works by Marius Petipa. The commentary is based on diaries, memoirs and letters of persons from the Grand Duke’s inner circle (including his father, Emperor Nicholas I and his mother, Empress Alexandra Feodorovna), Russian and foreign press, rare archival, musical and manuscript materials. The information contained in the article will be useful not only for art historians, but also for literary and cultural historians. 

Acknowledgements

The author wishes to express his thanks to Dr. Maria Shcherbakova (Mariinsky Theatre, Music Library and Archives), Dr. Alexey Savelyev (M. Gorky Scientific Library at St.Petersburg State University, Department of Rare Books and Manuscripts), Dr. Alla Semenyuk (Russian State Library, Department of Music Publications and Audio Recordings), Dr. Elena Mikhailova (National Library of Russia, Department of Manuscripts), Sofia Pepelzhi (National Library of Russia, Department of Music Publications), Petr Pospelov, Dr. Larisa Lunyakova.

References

1. Adam, Adolphe. 2003. Vospominaniya muzykanta [Souvenirs d’un musicien], translated by Elena F. Ovcharenko-Chernodubrovskaya. Мoscow: MАKS Press. (In Russian).

2. “Adol’f Adan i devitsa Sheri Kuro [Adolf Adan and Mlle Chérie Couraud]”. 1840. Severnaya pchela [Northern Bee], no. 200 (Sept. 6), 1–3.
3. Blok, Lyubov D. 1987. Klassicheskiy tanets. Istoriya i sovremennost’ [Classical Dance. History and Modernity]. Мoscow: Iskusstvo. (In Russian).

4. Boglacheva, Irina A. 2016. “Frantsuzskiy tantsovshchik Sharl’ Lashuk v Sankt-Peterburge, 1832–1841 [French Dancer Charles Lachoucq in St. Petersburg, 1832–1841].” In Rossiya — Frantsiya. Alliance kul’tur: Materialy XXII Tsarskosel’skoy nauchnoy konferentsii [Russia — France. Alliance of Cultures: Proceedings of the XXII Tsarskoye Selo Scientific Conference], vol. 1, edited by Iraida Bott, 83–92. St. Petersburg: Serebryanyy vek. (In Russian).

5. Bondarenko, Vyacheslav V. 2004. Vyazemskiy [Vyazemsky]. Мoscow: Molodaya gvardiya. (In Russian).

6. Bronfin, Elena F. 1973. “Adan [Adam].” Muzykal’naya entsiklopediya [Music Encyclopedia], edited by Yuri Keldysh, vol. 1, 54. Мoscow: Sovetskaya entsiklopediya. (In Russian).

7. Burdin, Fedor A. 1886. “Vospominaniya artista ob Imperatore Nikolae Pavloviche [The Artist’s Reminiscences of Emperor Nikolai Pavlovich].” Istoricheskiy vestnik [History Herald], no. 23, 144–53. (In Russian).

8. Burlaka, Yuriy P., and Anna P. Grutsynova. 2021. Antologiya baletnogo libretto. Rossiya 1800–1917. Sankt-Peterburg. Blash., Val’berkh, Didlo, Dyupor, Leon, Le Pik, Malavern’, Perro, Tal’oni, Tityus [An Anthology of Ballet Libretto. Russia 1800–1917. Saint-Petersburg. Blache, Valberkh, Didelot, Duport, Leon, Le Picq, Malavergne, Perrot, Taglioni, Titus]. St. Petersburg: Lan’; Planeta muzyki. (In Russian).

9. Vazem, Ekaterina O. 2009. Zapiski baleriny Sankt-Peterburgskogo Bol’shogo teatra. 1867–1884 [Memoirs of a Ballerina of the St. Petersburg Bolshoi Theatre. 1867–1884]. St. Petersburg: Lan’; Planeta muzyki. (In Russian).

10. “Vnutrennie izvestiya. Khronika [Home News. Chronicle].” 1875. Golos [Voice], no 28 (Jan. 28 / Feb. 9), 2. (In Russian).

11. Wolff, Alexander I. 1877. Khronika peterburgskikh teatrov. S kontsa 1826 do nachala 1855 goda [Chronicle of St. Petersburg Theaters. From the End of 1826 to the Beginning of 1855], vol. 1. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya R. Golike. (In Russian).

12. Kuz’min, Yury A., ed. 2008. “Vospominaniya P. A. Kuskova o velikom knyaze Konstantine Nikolaeviche [Platon Kuskov’s Reminiscences of Grand Duke Konstantin Nikolaevitch].” Istoricheskiy arkhiv [Historical Archive], no. 4, 157–96. (In Russian).

13. Sheremetev, Sergey D., ed. 1880. P.  A. Vyazemskiy. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy [P. A. Vyazemsky. The Complete Works], vol. 4. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya M. M. Stasyulevicha. (In Russian).

14. Sheremetev, Sergey D., ed. 1896. P.  A. Vyazemskiy. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy [P. A. Vyazemsky. The Complete Works], vol. 12. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya M. M. Stasyulevicha. (In Russian).

15. Gerstein, Emma G. 1964. Sud’ba Lermontova [Lermontov’s Fate]. Moscow: Sovetskiy pisatel’. (In Russian).

16. Gal’perinа, Bella D., and Boris P. Milovidov, eds. 2006. A. V. Golovnin. Materialy dlya zhizneopisaniya tsarevicha i velikogo knyazya Konstantina Nikolaevicha [A. V. Golovnin. Materials for the Biography of Tsarevich and Grand Duke Konstantin Nikolaevich]. St. Petersburg: D.A.R.K. (In Russian).

17. Grutsynova, Anna P. 2019. “Adan [Adam].” Muzykal’nyy Peterburg. Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar’, XIX vek, 1801–1861 [Musical Petersburg. Encyclopedic Dictionary, 19th Century, 1801–1861], edited by Natalia A. Ogarkova, vol. 15, 21–43. St. Petersburg: Kompozitor • Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).

18. Grutsynova, Anna P. 2019. Zapadnoevropeyskiy romanticheskiy balet: libretto, muzyka, postanovka, kritika [Western European Romantic Ballet: Libretto, Music, Production, Criticism]. Saratov: Sobinov Saratov State Conservatory. (In Russian).

19. Grutsynova, Anna P. 2021. “To the Question of Ballet for Children in the History of Domestic Choreographic Art.” Vestnik Akademii Russkogo baleta im. A. Ya. Vaganovoy / Bulletin of Vaganova Ballet Academy, no. 2, 18–33. (In Russian).

20. Grutsynova, Anna P. 2017. “Peterburgskie ‘priklyucheniya’ Adol’fa Adana [Petersburg ‘Adventures’ of Adolf Adam].” In Muzykal’nyy Petersburg. Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar’, XIX  vek, 1801–1861 [Musical Petersburg. Encyclopedic Dictionary, 19th Century, 1801–1861], edited by Natalia A. Ogarkova, vol. 14, 56–67. St. Petersburg: Kompozitor • Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).

21. Grutsynova, Anna P. 2011. Trinadtsat’ baletov Adol’ fa Adana [Thirteen Ballets by Adolf Adam]. Moscow: Alteks. (In Russian).

22. Grutsynova, Anna P. 2010. “Frantsuzskiy balet dlya russkoy stseny. K istorii postanovki baleta ‘Morskoy razboynik’ A. Adana — F. Tal’oni [French Ballet for the Russian Stage. On the History of the Production of the Ballet ‘L’Écumeur de mer’ by A. Adam — F. Taglioni].” In Russkie muzykal’nye arkhivy za rubezhom. Zarubezhnye muzykal’nye arkhivy v Rossii [Russian Music Archives Abroad. Foreign Music Archives in Russia], vol. 5, compiled and edited by Irina V. Brezhneva and Galina M. Malinina, 175–85. Academic Papers of Tchaikovsky Moscow State Conservatory 66. Moscow: Moscow Conservatory Press. (In Russian).

23. Zotov, Rafail M. 1896. “Zapiski [Memoirs].” Istoricheskiy vestnik [History Herald], no. 65, 302–21. (In Russian).

24. “Zrelishcha [Spectacles].” 1839. Sanktpeterburgskie vedomosti [St. Petersburg Gazette], no. 232 (Oct. 11): 1050. (In Russian).

25. “Zrelishcha [Spectacles]”. 1840. Sanktpeterburgskie vedomosti [St. Petersburg Gazette], no. 28 (Febr. 4): 124. (In Russian).

26. “Zrelishcha [Spectacles].” 1839. Severnaya pchela [Northern Bee], no. 229 (Oct. 11): 916. (In Russian).

27. Korsunskiy, Ivan. N. 1889. “Po povodu poluveka so vremeni vozobnovleniya Zimnego dvortsa [On the Occasion of the Half-Century Since the Resumption of the Winter Palace].” Russkiy arkhiv [Russian Archive], no. 9: 98–111. (In Russian).

28. Krasovskaya, Vera M. 1958. Russkiy baletnyy teatr ot vozniknoveniya do serediny XIX veka [Russian Ballet Theater from its Origin to the Middle of the 19th Century]. Moscow; Leningrad: Iskusstvo.

29. Kulakov, Valeriy A. 1981. “Ogyust [Auguste].” Balet: Entsiklopediya [Ballet: Encyclopedia], edited by Yury N. Grigorovich, 380. Мoscow: Sovetskaya entsiklopediya. (In Russian).

30. Lyamina, Ekaterina E., and Natal’ya V. Samover. 1999. “Bednyy Zhozef”: zhizn’ i smert’ Iosifa Viel’gorskogo: Opyt biografii cheloveka 1830-kh godov [“Poor Joseph”: the Life and Death of Joseph Vielgorsky: An Experience in the Biography of a Person of the 1830s]. Moscow: Yazyki russkoy kul’tury. (In Russian).

31. Borisoglebskiy, Mikhail V., ed. 1938. Materialy po istorii russkogo baleta [Materials on the History of Russian Ballet], vol 1. Leningrаd: Leningr. gos. khoreogr. uchilishche. (In Russian).

32. Moiseev, Grigory A. 2020. “E. F. Napravnik’s Memoirs in the Mirror of the Grand Duke Konstantin Nikolaevich’s Personal Diaries.” Muzykovedenie [Musicology], no. 11, 12–25. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.25791/musicology.11.2020.1157.

33. Moiseev, Grigory A. 2018. “The Grand Dukes Romanovs’ Personal Diaries as a Musical and Historical Source (the 2nd Half of the 19th Century).” Nauchnyy vestnik Moskovskoy konservatorii / Journal of Moscow Conservatory 9, no. 3: 8–77. (In Russian). https://doi. org/10.26176/mosconsv.2018.34.3.01.

34. Moiseev, Grigory A. 2021. “Mozartiana of the Marble Palace: On the History of Family Listening and Performing Traditions (1830–1890s)].” Muzykovedenie [Musicology], no. 8, 3–18. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.25791/musicology.8.2021.1204.

35. Moiseev, Grigory A. 2019. “Otrazhenie russkoy i evropeyskoy opernoy zhizni v dnevnikakh velikogo knyazya Konstantina Nikolaevicha (1830–1880-e gg.) [Reflection of Russian and European Opera Life in the Diaries of Grand Duke Konstantin Nikolaevich (1830–1880s.)].” In Opera v muzykal’nom teatre: istoriya i sovremennost’ [Opera in Music Theater: History and Modernity], materials of the Fourth International Scientific Conference, November 11–15, 2019, vol. 2, edited by Irina P. Susidko, 173–80. Moscow: Gnesin Russian Academy of Music. (In Russian).

36. Moiseev, Grigory A. 2013. “P. I. Tchaikovsky and Grand Duke Konstantin Nikolayevich. The Story of Their Relationship.” Nauchnyi vestnik Moskovskoy konservatorii / Journal of Moscow Conservatory 4, no. 3: 136–67. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.26176/mosconsv.2013.14.3.007.

37. Nikitenko, Aleksandr V. 1955–1956. Dnevnik [Diary]. Edited by Ieremiya Ya. Ayzenshtok. Moscow: Goslitizdat. (In Russian).

38. Nil’skiy, Aleksandr A. 1900. Zakulisnaya khronika 1856–1894 [Off-Stage Chronicle 1856–1894]. St. Petersburg: Obshhestvennaya pol’za. (In Russian).

39. “Novye muzykal’nye sochineniya [New Musical Compositions].” 1840. Biblioteka dlya chteniya [The Reader’s Library] 17, no. 7, 82.

40. Ol’ga Nikolaevna, Grand Duchess of Russia. 2000. “Son yunosti: Vospominaniya. 1825–1846 [The Golden Dream of My Youth. 1825–1846].” In Nikolay I. Muzh. Otets. Imperator [Nicholas I. Husband. Father. Emperor], edited by Natalia I. Azarovа, 174–329. Moscow: Slovo. (In Russian).

41. Brezhneva, Irina V., Galina V. Karminskaya, and Emma B. Rassina, eds. 1988. Otechestvennye izdaniya pervoy poloviny XIX veka [Domestic Editions of the First Half of the 19th Century], consolidated catalog, vol. 1, issue 1. Moscow: [s. n.]. (In Russian).

42. “Ot’ezzhayushchie za granitsu [The Departing Abroad].” 1840. Pribavlenie k Sanktpeterburgskim vedomostyam [Addition to the Sankt-Peterburgskie Vedomosti], no. 39 (Febr. 17): 396.

43. Pashkova, Tat’yana L. 2014. Imperator Nikolay I i ego sem’ya v Zimnem dvortse [Emperor Nicholas I and His Family in the Winter Palace], vol. 1. St. Petersburg: Izd-vo Gos. Ermitazha. (In Russian).

44. Zakharovа, Larisa G., and Sergey V. Mironenko, eds. 2008. Perepiska tsesarevicha Aleksandra Nikolaevicha s imperatorom Nikolaem I, 1838–1839 [Correspondence of Tsesarevich Alexander Nikolaevich with Emperor Nicholas I, 1838–1839]. Bumagi Doma Romanovykh. Moscow: ROSSPEN. (In Russian).

45. “Peterburgskaya vsyachina [Petersburg Miscellanea].” 1840. Syn Otechestva [Son of the Fatherland] 2, no. 1: 243.

46. Boglacheva, Irina A. 2014. Peterburgskiy balet. Tri veka: khronika [St. Petersburg Ballet. Three Centuries: Chronicle], vol. 2. St. Petersburg: [s. n.]. (In Russian).

47. Konaev, Sergey А., ed. 2018. M. Petipa. “Memuary” i dokumenty [M. Petipa. “Memoirs” and Documents]. Moscow: Navona. (In Russian and French).

48. Petrova, Galina V. 2014. “Posvyashchenie ‘Fantasticheskoy simfonii’ Gektora Berlioza Nikolayu I. Uspekh ili neuspekh? [Dedication of Hector Berlioz’s ‘Fantastic Symphony’ to Emperor Nicholas I. Success or Failure?].” In Muzyka v kul’turnom prostranstve Evropy — Rossii. Sobytiya. Lichnost’. Istoriya [Music in the Cultural Space of Europe — Russia. Events. Personality. History], edited by Natalia Ogarkova, 104–18. St. Petersburg: Russian Institute of Art History. (In Russian and French).

49. “Pis’mo kompozitora Ad. Adama iz Rossii [A Letter from the Composer Adam from Russia].” 1899. Russkaya muzykal’naya gazeta [Russian Musical Newspaper], no. 42: 1039–42. (In Russian).

50. Pleshcheev, Aleksandr A. 2009. Nash balet (1673–1899): Balet v Rossii do nachala XIX stoletiya i balet v S.-Peterburge do 1899 g. [Our Ballet (1673–1899): Ballet in Russia until the Beginning of the 19th Century and Ballet in St. Petersburg until 1899]. St. Petersburg: Lan’; Planeta muzyki. (In Russian).

51. Pogozhev, Vladimir P. 1906. Stoletie organizatsii imperatorskikh moskovskikh teatrov (Opyt istoricheskogo obzora) [Centenary of the Organization of the Imperial Moscow Theaters (Experience of Historical Review)], vol. 1. St. Petersburg: Direktsiya imp. teatrov. (In Russian).

52. Barenboym, Lev A., ed. 1983. A. G. Rubinshteyn. Literaturnoe nasledie [A. G. Rubinstein. Literary Heritage], vol. 1. Moscow: Muzyka. (In Russian).

53. Ryleeva, Mariya A. 2010. “Ital’yanskaya balerina Elena Kornal’ba na peterburgskoy stsene [Italian Ballerina Elena Kornalba on the St. Petersburg Stage].” Vestnik Akademii Russkogo baleta im. A. Ya. Vaganovoy / Bulletin of Vaganova Ballet Academy, no. 2, 191–215. (In Russian).

54. Sveshnikova, Alisa L. 2008. Peterburgskie sezony Artura Sen-Leona. 1859–1870 [The Petersburg Seasons of Arthur Saint-Leon. 1859–1870]. St. Petersburg: Baltiyskie sezony. (In Russian).

55. Sidorova, Anna N. 2019. Obrazovat’ v detyakh um, serdtse i dushu. Vospitanie velikikh knyazey v sem’yakh imperatorov Nikolaya I i Aleksandra II [To Form the Mind, Heart and Soul in Children. Education of Grand Dukes in the Families of Emperors Nicholas I and Alexander II]. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole Muzeon. (In Russian).

56. Skal’kovskiy, Konstantin. 1895. O zhenshchinakh. Mysli starye i novye [On Women. Reflections — Olden and Novel]. 9th edition. St. Petersburg: A. S. Suvorin. (In Russian).

57. Sklyarevskaya, Inna R. 2017. Tal’oni. Fenomen i mif [Taglioni. Phenomenon and Myth]. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. (In Russian).

58. Slonimskiy, Yuriy I. 1974. Baletnye stroki Pushkina [Pushkin’s Ballet Lines]. Leningrad: Iskusstvo. Leningr. otd-nie. (In Russian).

59. Stukolkin, Timofey A. 1895. “Vospominaniya artista imperatorskikh teatrov, zapisannye po ego rasskazu A. Val’bergom [Memoirs of an Artist of the Imperial Theaters, Recorded According to His Narrative by A. Valberg].” Artist [Artist] 46, no. 2: 117–25. (In Russian).

60. Taglioni, Filippo. 1840. Morskoy razboynik, balet v dvukh deystviyakh, soch. g. Tal’oni, muzyka soch. g. Adama. Predstavleno v 1-y raz na Bol’shom teatre 5-go fevralya 1840 goda [‘L’Écumeur de mer’, Ballet in two acts, by F. Taglioni; music by A. Adam. Presented for the First Time in Bolshoi Theatre on February 5, 1840]. St. Petersburg: tip. I. Glazunova. (In Russian).

61. Taglioni, Filippo. 1841. Morskoy razboynik (Le pirate), balet v trekh deystviyakh, soch. g. Tal’oni, postavlen na zdeshney stsene baletmeysterom imp. mosk. teatra g. Gerino, muz[yka] soch. Adol’ fa Adama [‘L’Écumeur de mer,’ Ballet in three acts, composed by m-r Taglioni, staged on the local stage by the Choreographer of Moscow Imperial Theatre m-r Gerino, music by Adolfe Adam]. Moscow: tip. I. Smirnova. (In Russian).

62. “Teatr i muzyka [Theater and Music].” 1871. Peterburgskaya gazeta [St. Petersburg Newspaper], no. 1 (Jan. 3), 3. (In Russian).

63. “Teatral’noe ekho [Theatrical Echo].” 1872. Peterburgskaya gazeta [St. Petersburg Newspaper], no. 10 (Jan. 18), 2. (In Russian).

64. “Teatral’noe ekho [Theatrical Echo].” 1875. Peterburgskaya gazeta [St. Petersburg Newspaper], no. 16 (Jan. 28), 2. (In Russian).

65. “Teatral’nye novosti [Theater News].” 1870. Peterburgskaya gazeta [St. Petersburg Newspaper], no. 161 (Nov. 3), 3. (In Russian).

66. Teatral’nyy al’bom [Theatrical Album]. 1842. Vol. 2. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya K. Kraya. (In Russian).

67. Fedorchenko, Olga A. 2018. “‘Nestor’ of Russian Ballet: Nikolai Osipovich Golts. 1800– 1880.” Vestnik Akademii Russkogo baleta im. A. Ya. Vaganovoy / Bulletin of Vaganova Ballet Academy, no. 1, 33–41. (In Russian).

68. Khudekov, Sergey N. 1918. Istoriya tantsev [The History of Dances]. Vol. 4. Petrograd: tip. “Petrogradskoy gazety” S. N. Khudekova. (In Russian).

69. Shlugleyt, Genrikh M. 1981. “Morskoy razboynik [L’Écumeur de mer].” In Balet: Entsiklopediya [Ballet Encyclopedia], edited by Yury N. Grigorovich, 354. Мoscow: Sovetskaya entsiklopediya. (In Russian).

70. “Chronique étrangère.” 1840. Revue et gazette musicale de Paris, no. 15 (20 février): 124.

71. “Chronique étrangère.” 1840. Revue et gazette musicale de Paris, no. 23 (19 mars): 188.

72. Cucchi, Claudina. 1904. Venti anni di palcoscenico. Ricordi artistici. Rome: Enrico Voghera.

73. Feldman, Ann E. 1990. “Being Heard: Women Composers and Patrons at the 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition.” Notes 47, no. 1 (September): 7–20. https://doi.org/10.2307/940531.

74. Letellier, Robert I., and Nicholas L. Fuller. 2023. Adolphe Adam, Master of the Romantic Ballet, 1830–1856. Newcastle-upon-Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

75. “Musique nouvelle publiee par les éditeurs de Paris.” 1840. Revue et gazette musicale de Paris, no. 66 (22 novembre): 566.

76. Pougin, Arthur. 1877. Adolphe Adam: sa vie, sa carrière, ses mémoires artistiques. Paris: Charpentier.

77. Pougin, Arthur., ed. 1899. “Quelques lettres inédites de musiciens célèbres.” Ménestrel 38 (17 septembre), 1.

78. “Spettacoli d’oggi.” 1857. Gazzetta Piemontese, no. 47 (Febbraio 24), 3.

79. Studwell, William E. 1987. Adolphe Adam and Léo Delibes: A Guide to Research. New York; London: Garland.

80. “Taglioni.” 1840. New Monthly Belle Assemblée. A Magazine of Literature and Fashion, under the Immediate Patronage of Her Royal Highness the Duchess of Kent, vol. XII (January to June), 329.

81. Marion Kant, ed. 2007. The Cambridge Companion to Ballet. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

82. “Theater.” 1840. St. Petersburgische Zeitung, no. 28 (Februar 4/16): 134.

83. “Ultime notizie.” 1857. Gazzetta Piemontese, no. 49 (Febbraio 26), 3.