“Pastorale” by Beethoven: Between a Musical Portrait of Nature and Symphonic “Psychedelia”

Abstract

The article is devoted to the consideration of Beethoven’s Sixth Symphony in the context of the traditions of pastoral instrumental music and, more broadly, the genre of European pastoral, which manifested itself in almost all types and kinds of music. The main focus is on the intersection of retrospective and prospective paradigms of the genre, which makes it possible to highlight the “Pastoral” phenomenon in more detail. For the representativity of historical comparison, the author uses the generalized scheme “yesterday — today — tomorrow”, placing the opus by Vienna Classic in its center. This scheme is not thought of mechanically as an irreversible vector of time, but rather typologically, when “yesterday” can be present in “today” and even “tomorrow”. This scheme helps to accentuate significant moments in the counterpoint of such lines defining the genre “texture” of Beethoven’s work as the old tradition of the Christmas pastoral, the “naturalized” georgics of the Enlightenment, characteristic instrumental music with the transition occurring in it from a rhetorical depiction of nature to its sensory‑emotional experience. The significance of Beethoven’s “Pastoral Symphony” in subsequent history is emphasized — both as an example of a genre, and as an ethical‑philosophical concept stimulating a cultural dialogue (Symphonie Fantastique by H. Berlioz), and as a recognizable musical topos of a classical pastoral, lost by the disharmonious world of the postmodern era (Sinfonia by L. Berio).

References

1. Berlioz, H. (1956). Kriticheskiy ocherk o simfoniyakh Beethovena [A Critical Essay on Beethoven’s Symphonies]. In H. Berlioz. Izbrannye stat’i [Selected Papers], edited, translated and commented by V. N. Aleksandrova and E. F. Bronfin, 166–205. Moscow, Muzgiz. (in Russian).

2. ____ (2011). Beethoven. Pis’ma [Letters]: in 4 vols, 2nd ed., Vol. 1: 1787–1811, edited and commented by N. L. Fishman and L. V. Kirillina, translated by L. S. Tovaleva and N. L. Fishman. Moscow, Muzyka. (in Russian).

3. Gruber, R. I. (1941). Istoriya muzykal’noy kul’tury [History of Musical Culture], Vol. I, Part. 2. Leningrad, Muzgiz. (in Russian).

4. Kirillina, L. V. (2009). Beethoven. Zhizn’ i tvorchestvo [Beethoven. Life and Work], Vol. I. Moscow, Moscow Conservatory Press. (in Russian).

5. Korobova, A. G. (2004). Ob odnom pastoral’nom “syuzhete” u H. Berlioza [On One Pastoral “Plot” From H. Berlioz]. Semantika muzykal'nogo yazyka [Semantics of Musical Language], Proceedings of International Conference, 236–41. Moscow, Gnesins Russian Academy of Music. (in Russian).

6. Korobova, A. G. (2007). Pastoral’ v muzyke evropeyskoy traditsii: k teorii i istorii zhanra [Pastoral in the Music of the European Tradition: Towards the Theory and History of the Genre], Doctor Thesis. Yekateringburg, Mussorgsky Ural State Conservatory. (in Russian).

7. Nef, K. (1938). Istoriya zapadnoevropeyskoy muzyki [History of West‑European Music], 2nd ed. Moscow, Gosmuzizdat. (in Russian).

8. B[ischoffs], L. (1866). Die Pastoral‑Sinfonieen von Justin Heinrich Knecht (1784) und Ludwig van Beethoven (1808). Niederrheinische Musik-Zeitung für Kunstfreude und Künstler, XIV Jahrgang, Nr. 48 (1. December 1866), 379–81. Available at: http://libserv14. princeton.edu/bluemtn/?a=d&d=bmtnabi18661201‑01.2.3 (accessed 05.07.2020).

9. Brown, H. M. Symphonia [I, II]. In The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, edited by St. Sadie, 2nd ed, Vol. 24, 165–73. London and New York, Macmillan.

10. Jones, D. W. (1995). Beethoven: The Pastoral Symphony. Cambridge and New York, Cambridge University Press.

11. Jung, H. (2003). Justin Heinrich Knecht (1752–1817). Ein oberschwäbischer Komponist im Umfeld der Wiener Klassik. BC-Heimatkundliche Blätter für den Kreis Biberach, Jg. 26, H. 1, 24–34. Available at: http://www.gfh‑biberach.de/Hefte/BC‑Heimatkundliche‑ Bl%C3%A4tter‑f%C3%BCr‑den‑Kreis‑Biberach/J26H1S24.pdf (accessed 04.07.2020).

12. Jung, H. und Engel, H. (1997). Pastorale. In Die Musik in Geschichte und Gegenwart, 2‑e Ausgabe, herausgegeben von L. Finscher, Sachteil 7, 1499–509. Kassel, Bärenreiter.

13. Schmenner, R. (1998). Die Pastorale: Beethoven, das Gewitter und der Blitzableiter. Kassel, Bärenreiter.

14. Stainer, J. (1914). Wind Instruments — Sumponyah; Sampunia; Sumphonia; Symphonia (Chapter VII) // J. Stainer. Music of the Bible, with Some Account of the Development of Modern Musical Instruments from Ancient Types, new edition by Fr. W. Galpin. London, Novello. Available at: http://www.katapi.org.uk/MusicOfTheBible/Ch7.htm (accessed 02.07.2020).

15. Will, R. (2002). The Characteristic Symphony in the Age of Haydn and Beethoven. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.