Humorous Lamentations of the Penza Region

Abstract

The Russian lamentation tradition enjoys constant interest from representatives of various scientific schools. At the same time, their main attention is directed to the study of wedding lamentations of individual regions of Russia. The mournful traditions of the Penza region are rather modestly reflected in publications, and humorous lamentations and related rituals and games have not been studied at all to date. In this regard, the subject of our study is humorous lamentations in the context of the ritual or game situation that generates them. The study is based on expeditionary (field) materials from different areas of the Penza region, which made it possible to identify a system of calendar farewells-“funerals” of various characters. In addition, elements of funeral rites are so significant for the local Penza tradition that they are also found in a traditional wedding. Lamentations sounding in various situations exhibit different properties at different levels of organization. Thus, the texts of humorous lamentations represent a free improvisation concerning the appearance of the character, his health and containing an imitation of physiological crying. The tunes of the humorous laments are close to funeral laments in their modal and pitch organization: a stable modal structure based on a major third despite unstable pitch is a defining feature of the genre. In addition, a group form of humorous laments has been recorded for the first time, which corrects the established idea of  the Penza lament tradition.

References

1. Al’tshuler, Marina S. 2007. “Russkie pokhoronnye prichitaniya. Vidy, formy, genezis, bytovanie [Russian Funeral Lamentations. Types, Forms, Genesis, Existence].” Ph.D. diss., Tchaikovsky Moscow State Conservatory. (In Russian).

2. Al’tshuler, Marina S. 2020. “Pokhoronnye prichitaniya khoperskikh kazakov [Funeral Lamentations of Khopyor Cossacks].” Nauchnyy vestnik Moskovskoy konservatorii / Journal of Moscow Conservatory 11, no. 4: 132–45. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.26176/mosconsv.2020.43.4.007.

3. Astrov, Nikolay. 1905. “Krest’yanskaya svad’ba v s. Zagoskine Penzenskago uezda (bytovoy ocherk) [Peasant Wedding in the Village of Zagoskino, Penza District (Everyday Life Essay)].” Zhivaya starina [Living Antiquity], issue 3–4, 415–58. (In Russian).

4. Gilyarova, Natalia N. 1990. “Kuz’ma i Dem’yan — ‘kuryatniki,’ ‘kashniki,’ rabotniki [Kuzma and Demyan — ‘Poultrymans,’ ‘Cooks,’ Workers].” Narodnoye tvorchestvo [Folk Art], no. 11, 26–29. (In Russian).

5. Gilyarova, Natalia N. 1996. “Osobennosti svadebnykh traditsiy naseleniya Penzenskoy oblasti [Features of Wedding Traditions of the Population of the Penza Region].” Etnograficheskoe obozrenie [Ethnographic Review], no. 2, 30–50. (In Russian).

6. Gilyarova, Natalia N. 2004. “Prichitaniya Penzenskoy zemli [Lamentations of the Penza Land].” Muzykovedenie [Musicology], no. 2, 33–47. (In Russian).

7. Gilyarova, Natalia N. 2010. “Pesni svadebnogo obryada Penzenskoy oblasti (k probleme regional’noy stilistiki) [Songs of the Wedding Rite of the Penza Region (to the Problem of Regional Stylistics)].” Muzykovedenie [Musicology], no. 11, 16–24. (In Russian).

8. Gorizontov, A. 1859. “Khozyaystvenno-statisticheskoe opisanie Penzenskogo uezda [Economic and Statistical Description of the Penza District].” Trudy Imperatorskogo Vol’nago Ekonomicheskogo obshchestva [Works of the Imperial Free Economic Society], vol. 1, section 2: Sel’skoye khozyaystvo i vspomogatel’nye veshchestva [Agriculture and Auxiliary Substances], 95–159. (In Russian).

9. Danchenkova, Natalia Yu. 1999. “Prichetnyy areal mezhdurech’ya Klyaz’my i Oki v ikh srednem techenii (Vladimirskaya oblast’) [Laments of the Area Between Klyazma and Oka Rivers in Their Middle Reaches (Vladimir Region)].” In Kartografirovanie i areal’nye issledovaniya v fol’kloristike [Mapping and Areal Research in Folklore Studies], collected works, issue 15. Moscow: Gnessin State Musical Pedagogical Institute, 147–69. (In Russian).

10. Еngovatova, Margarita A. 2011. “Plachevaya kul’tura Zakam’ya: voprosy regional’noy spetsifiki [Lament Culture of Zakamye: Issues of Regional Specificity].” In Otechestvennaya etnomuzykologiya: istoriya nauki, metody issledovaniya, perspektivy razvitiya [Domestic Ethnomusicology: History of Science, Research Methods, Development Prospects], proceedings of the International scientific conference, September 30 — October 3, 2010, vol. 2. St. Petersburg: University Educational District of St. Petersburg and Leningrad Region, 37–47. (In Russian).

11. Efimenkova, Borislava B. 2008. Vostochnoslavyanskaya svad’ba i ee muzykal’noe napolnenie: vvedenie v problematiku [East Slavic Wedding and Its Musical Content: Introduction to the Problematics]. Moscow: Gnessin Russian Academy of Music. (In Russian).

12. Zaytseva, Еlena A. 2006. “Muzyka russkogo narodnogo kalendarya v kontekste traditsionnykh natsional’nykh verovaniy [Music of the Russian Folk Calendar in the Context of Traditional National Beliefs].” Extended abstract of Ph.D. diss., Tchaikovsky Moscow State Conservatory. (In Russian).

13. Zelenin, Dmitriy K. 1915. Opisaniye rukopisey uchenogo arkhiva Imperatorskogo Russkogo Geograficheskogo Obshchestva [Description of Manuscripts of the Scientific Archive of the Imperial Russian Geographical Society], issue 2, section XXVIII: Penzenskaya guberniya [Penza Province]. Petrograd: 967–87. (In Russian).

14. Zelenin, Dmitriy K. 1995. Izbrannyye trudy. Ocherki russkoy mifologii: umershie neestestvennoy smert’yu i rusalki [Selected Works. Essays on Russian Mythology: Those Who Died an Unnatural Death and Mermaids]. Moscow: Indrik. (In Russian).

15. Kondrat’eva Tat’yana G. 2010. “O genezise literaturnykh istochnikov v traditsionnom pesennom fol’klore Penzenskoy oblasti [On the Genesis of Literary Sources in the Traditional Song Folklore of the Penza Region].” Izvestiya Samarskogo nauchnogo tsentra Rossiyskoy akademii nauk [Bulletin of Samara Scientific Center of the Russian Academy of Sciences], vol. 12, no. 3–2: 531–35. (In Russian).

16. Kondrat’eva, Tat’yana G. 2017. “Tipologiya narodnykh pesen literaturnogo proiskhozhdeniya v kontekste muzykal’nogo fol’klora Penzenskoy oblasti [Typology of Folk Songs of Literary Origin in the Context of the Musical Folklore of the Penza Region].” Extended abstract of Ph.D. diss., Sobinov Saratov State Conservatory. (In Russian).

17. Matveeva, Irina A., and Anna Yu. Gurina. 2017. “Pokhorony Kostromushki v sele Ushinka Zemetchinskogo rayona Penzenskoy oblasti [Funeral of Kostromushka in the Village of Ushinka, Zemetchinsky District, Penza Region].” Trudy konferentsii “Pokrovskie dni” [Proceedings of the conference “Pokrov days”], no. 8, 12–24. (In Russian).

18. Matveeva, Irina A. 2022. “Prazdnik svyatykh Kuz’my i Dem’yana v Penzenskoy oblasti [Feast of Saints Kosma and Damian in the Penza Region].” In Kul’tura: problemy teorii, istorii, praktiki [Culture: Problems of Theory, History, and Practice], proceedings of the 5th interregional scientific and practical conference. Penza: PSU Publishing House, 57–64. (In Russian).

19. Matlin, Mikhail G. 2013. “Svadebnaya igra v ‘pokoynika’: k probleme genezisa smekhovykh form v russkoy traditsionnoy svad’be [Wedding Game of the ‘Decedent’: On the Problem of the Genesis of Comic Forms in the Russian Traditional Wedding].” In Sborniki konferentsiy NITS Sotsiosfera [Proceedings of the conferences of the Research Center Sociosphere], no. 39, 128–42. (In Russian).

20. Matlin, Mikhail G. 2014. “Svadebnaya igra v ‘pokoynika’ v prazdnichno-obryadovom prostranstve russkogo sela [Wedding Game of the ‘Decedent’ in the Festive and Ritual Space of the Russian Village].” Izvestiya vysshikh uchenykh zavedeniy. Povolzhskiy region. Gumanitarnyye nauki [News of the Higher Scientific Institutions. Volga region. Humanitarian Sciences], no. 1, 121–33. (In Russian).

21. Nikol’sky, V. 1883. “Nravy i obychai zhiteley sela Vladykina. Obydennaya zhizn’ krest’yan [Customs and Traditions of the Inhabitants of the Village of Vladykino. Everyday life of Peasants].” Penzenskie eparkhial’nye vedomosti [Penza Diocesan Gazette], no. 8, 9–20. (In Russian).

22. Redkina, Irina A. 2007. “Pokhorony Goryuna v s. Solovtsovka Penzenskogo rayona Penzenskoy oblasti [Goryun’s Funeral in the Village of Solovtsovka, Penza District, Penza Region].” Etnografiya Tsentral’nogo Chernozem’ya [Ethnography of the Central Black Earth Region], collected researches, issue 6, 91–98. (In Russian).

23. Reznichenko, Evgeniya B. 2013. “Prichitaniya vostochnogo Pomor’ya s podvizhnymi zvukovysotnymi parametrami [Lamentations of the Eastern Pomorye with Movable Pitch Parameters].” Voprosy etnomuzykoznaniya [Issues of Ethnomusicology], no. 3, 48–57. (In Russian).

24. “Svadebnyye obychai i pesni krest’yan Saranskogo uezda (iz zapisok Abr. R-va) [Wedding Customs and Songs of Peasants of the Saransk District (From the Notes of the Abr. R-va)].” 1864. Penzenskiye gubernskiye vedomosti [Penza Provincial Gazette], no. 17: 101–15. (In Russian).

25. Tarkhova, Alla A., and Nikolay S. Malkov. 2006. Selo moe, selo moe rodnoye. Pesni sela Kanaevki Gorodishchenskogo rayona Penzenskoy oblasti [My Village, My Native Village. Songs of the Village of Kanaevka, Gorodishchensky District, Penza Region], issue 1. Penza: Rostra [et al.]. (In Russian).

26. Tarkhova, Alla A. 2010. Traditsionnaya kul’tura russkoy derevni serediny XIX — XX vv. (na materialakh Penzenskoy oblasti) [Traditional Culture of the Russian Village in the Mid-19th — 20th Centuries (Based on the Materials from the Penza Region)]. Penza: Rostra. (In Russian).

27. Feodosievsky, I. 1890. “V den’ Pyatidesyatnitsy (protiv nekhristianskogo obychaya ‘pokhoron goryuna’) [On the Day of Pentecost (Against the Non-Christian Custom of ‘Burying a Mourner’)].” Besedy i poucheniya k prostomu narodu pastyrey Penzenskoy eparkhii. Prilozheniye k “Penzenskim eparkhial’nym vedomostyam” za 1890 g. [Conversations and Teachings to the Common People of the Pastors of the Penza Diocese. Supplement to “Penza Diocesan Gazette” for 1890], vol. 10, 26–28. (In Russian).

28. Feoktistov, Pavel V. 1860. Obryady krest’yan pri svad’bakh v Penzenskoy gubernii [Peasant Wedding Rites in the Penza Province]. Penzenskiye gubernskiye vedomosti [Penza Provincial Gazette], no. 5: 42–44, no. 6: 52–55, no. 7: 59–62, no. 8: 70–73, no. 9: 81–84. (In Russian).