On Richard Wagner’s Music in the Context of Werner Herzog’s Films: Regards the Dialog with Cultural Heritage of the Past

Abstract

In this article the object of consideration is the films of Werner Herzog. These movies are “philosophical images” hidden behind the mask of an art or documentary narrative. The classical music has the great influence on the meaning formation in Herzog’s cinematic universe. In Herzog's films the music is interpreted not only as a soundtrack, but also as the mode of transmitting the additional meaning. For decades the constant interrelations between certain compositions and specific motion picture frames migrate from the one film to another. They have a function of audio and video lexical items, which allows us to mark the special semantic role of music in Werner Herzog’s films. The other important feature of the director’s creative method is the dialogue with the German cultural heritage. In his films Herzog recreates the different genre models of the Golden age of German cinema. He turns to Richard Wagner as to the artist whose ideas have directly influenced over the state of German culture in the first half of the twentieth century and over the cinema as a new art. Herzog refers to Wagner’s music as to the phenomenon summarizing German romantic poetics. Numerous foreign studies on Werner Herzog are concentrated on the philosophical concept of his films. In a lesser degree, they consider the musical component of his films. This article defines the function of Wagner’s music in Herzog’s selected films in order to concretize their philosophical and artistic sense.

References

1. Aysner, L. (2010). Demonicheskiy ekran [Demonic Screen], translated by K. Timofeeva. Moscow, Rosebud Publishing; Post Modern Tekhnolodzhy. (in Russian).

2. Barsova, I. A. (2012). Simfonii Gustava Malera [The Symphonies of Gustav Mahler], revised version. Saint-Petersburg, Novikov Publishing House. (in Russian).

3. ________. Bunyuel’ o Bunyuele (1989). [Buñuel on Buñuel], translated by A. Braginkiy, T. Zlochevskaya, N. Nusinova, preface by K. Dolgov. Moscow, Raduga. (in Russian).

4. Belen’kiy, I. V. (2008). Lektsii po vseobshchej istorii kino. Godi bezzvuchiya [Lectures on the Universal History of Cinema. Years of Silence], Textbook in 2 vols. Moscow, GITR. (in Russian).

5. Wagner, R. (1978). Proizvedenie iskusstva budushchego [The Artwork of the Future]. In Wagner, R. Izbrannye raboty [Selected Works], collected and commented by I. Barsova and S. Osherova, introductory preface by A. Losev, 142–261. Moscow, Arts. (in Russian).

6. Gaykov, P. (2016). Verner Hertsog: «U menya net mobilnika, ya govoryu s lud’mi glaza v glaza» [Werner Hezog: «I don’t Have a Mobile Phone, I Talk to People Eye to Eye»]. Moscow, RIA Novosti Press. Available at: https://ria.ru/interview/20160926/1477856164. html (accessed 01.12.2018). (in Russian).

7. Grigorash, A. V. (2012). Gesamtkunstverk: k istorii ponyatiya v nemetskoy istoriografii [Gesamtkunstwerk: Towards the History of the Idea in German Historiography]. In Aktual’nie problemi teorii i istorii iskusstva [Actual Problems of Theory and History of Art], vol. 2, edited by A. Zakharova, 321–26. Saint-Petersburg, NP— Print. (in Russian).

8. Koronniy, O. (2016). Entsiklopedia Vernera Hertsoga [Werner Herzog Encyclopedia]. Available at: https://arzamas.academy/mag/373‑herzog (accessed 12.11.2018). (in Russian).

9. Krakauer, Z. (1977). Psihologicheskaya istoria nemetskogo kino. Ot Kalligari do Gitlera [From Caligari to Hitler: A Psychological History of the German Film], edited and commented by N. Abramova. Moscow, Arts. (in Russian).

10. Krasnova, G. V. (2016). Novoe nemetskoe kino vchera i segodnya [New German Cinema from Yesterday to Today]. Moscow, Kanon-plus. (in Russian).

11. Kronin, P. (2010). Znakomtes’ — Verner Hertsog [Herzog on Herzog], translated by E. Mikerina. Moscow, Rosebud Publishing. (in Russian).

12. Kuvshinova, M. (2016). «Ya sdelal fil’m vo slavu interneta». Verner Hercog — o novoy kartine, Ilone Maske i ekstremal’nom kinematografe [«I Made a Movie for the Glory of the Internet». Werner Herzog — About the New Film, Elon Musk and Extreme Cinema]. Available at: https://meduza.io/feature/2016/10/19/ya-sdelal-film-vo-slavuinterneta (accessed 12.11.2018). (in Russian).

13. Kyurten, Y., Volodina, E. (2013). Misticheskiy dar Vernera Hertsoga [Werner Herzog’s Mystical Gift]. Germany, DW. Available at: https://www.dw.com/ru/мистический-дар-вернера-херцога/a17001480 (accessed 13.11.2018). (in Russian).

14. Lebedev, S., Pospelova, R. (2000). Musicalatina: Latinskie teksty v muzyke i muzykal’noy nauke [Musica Latina. Latin Texts in Music and Musicology]. SaintPetersburg, Kompozitor. (in Russian). 197музыка и кино Художественный мир Вернера Херцога и место музыки в нем

15. Levchenko, Ya. (2011). Poslannik d’yavola (k 85‑letiyu Klausa Kinski) [The Devil’s Envoy (For Klaus Kinski's 85th Birthday)]. Available at: http://www.cinematheque.ru/ post/145959 (accessed 12.11.2018). (in Russian).

16. Messner, R. (1990). Hrustalny gorizont: Cherez Tibet k Everestu [The Crystal Horizon: Across Tibet to Mount Everest], translated and preface by V. Matveenko. Moscow, Planeta. (in Russian). 1

7. Nechaev, A. (2016). Popali v set’: Verner Hertsog predstavil svoy noviy fil’m ob Internete i gryozah tsifrovogo mira [Hit the Net: Werner Herzog Presented His New Film About the Internet and Dreams of the Digital World]. Rossiyskaya Gazeta [Russian Gazzete]. Available at: https://rg.ru/2016/09/29/verner-hercog-predstavil-svoj-novyjdokumentalnyj-film-ob-internete.html (accessed 12.11.2018). (in Russian).

18. _______. Noviy Zavet i Psaltir’ [New Testament and Psalter]. Minsk, The Gideons International. (in Russian).

19. Oboron, E., Burdo E. (2009). Verner Hertsog: «Ya mogu chitat' v chelovecheskom serdce» [Werner Herzog: «I Can Read the Human Heart»]. Available at: http://www. cinematheque.ru/post/138940/print/ (accessed 01.12.2018). (in Russian).

20. Popova, A. Master-class Vernera Hertsoga: polnaya stenogramma interviyu [Master class by Werner Herzog: full transcript of the interview]. Available at: https:// theoryandpractice.ru/posts/2388‑master-klassvernera-khertsoga-polnaya-stenogrammai-intervyu (accessed 11.11.2018). (in Russian).

21. Postanova, D. (2016). «Moi Fil’my — Meynstrim»: Interv’yu s Vernerom Hertsogom [«My Films are Mainstream»: Interview with Werner Herzog]. Available at: https:// cinemaholics.ru/mein-herz/ (accessed 01.12.2018). (in Russian).

22. Rovenko, E. V. (2018). Verner Hertsog i “zolotoy vek’ nemetskogo kinematografa: vossozdavaya kulturnuyu traditsiyu [Werner Herzog and the “Golden age” of German Cinema: Recreating a Cultural Tradition]. In Filosofiya tvorchestva [The Philosophy of Creativity], edited by N. Smirnova, I. Beskova, Vol. 4, Liki tvorchestva v mnogoobrazii sotsiokul’turnih praktik [Faces of Creativity in a Variety of Socio-Cultural Practices], 332–60. Moscow, RAS Institute of Philosophy, IInteLL. (in Russian).

23. Rychkov, K. N. (2011). «Zvezdnye voyny» Lukasa—Uil’yamsa: Gesamtkunstwerk Vozvrashchaetsya? [«Star Wars» by Lucas—Williams: Does the Gesamtkunstwerk Return?]. Nauchnyy vestnik Moskovskoy konservatorii [Journal of Moscow Conservatory], No. 3/2011, 177–93. (in Russian).

24. Sazonov, A. (2011). Verner Hertsog: «Vsekh razdrazhaet, chto ya snimayuraznoe kino» [Werner Herzog: «Everyone is Annoyed that I Shoot Different Movies»]. Available at: http://os.colta.ru/cinema/events/details/23381/?expand=yes#expand (accessed 01.12.2018). (in Russian).

25. Samutina, N. (2002). Rayner Verner Fassbinder i Verner Hertsog. Evropeyskiy chelovek: uprazhneniya v antropologii [Rainer Werner Fassbinder and Werner Herzog. European Man: An Exercise in Anthropology]. Moscow, Kinovedcheskie zapiski. Available at: http://www.kinozapiski.ru/ru/article/sendvalues/279/ (accessed 11.05.18). (in Russian).

26. Shak, T. (2014). Metodologiya analiza muzyki kino (k postanovke problemy) [Methodology of Analysis of Film Music (To the Problem Statement)]. In Zakadrovoe iskusstvo. Istoriya i teoriya kinomuzyki. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferencii [Voice-Over Art. History and Theory of Film Music. Materials of the International Scientific Conference], collected and edited by K. Rychkov. Moscow, Moscow Conservatory Press. (in Russian).

27. Adorno T. W., Eisler H. (2006). Komposition für den Film,mit einem Nachwort von Johannes C. Gall und einer DVD “Hanns Eislers Rockefeller-Filmmusik-Projekt 1940– 1942“, im Auftrag der Internationalen Hanns Eisler Gesellschaft, hrsg. von Johannes C. Gall. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.

28. Bush, S. W. (1911). Giving Musical Expression to the Drama. The Moving Picture World, Vol. 9. No. 15, 354.

29. Chen, J. (2013). The Impact of Richard Wagner on Werner Herzog’s Film “Nosferatu”, М. А. Thesis. Columbia, University of Missouri.

30. Cronin, P. (2002). Herzog on Herzog. London, Faber & Faber.

31. Evensen, K (2011). The Star Wars and Wagner’s Ring. Available at: http://www.thewagnerian.com/2011/06/star-wars-series-and-wagners-ring.html (accessed 12.11.2018).

32. Joe, J. (2010). Why Wagner and Cinema? Tolkien Was Wrong. In Wagner and Cinema, edited by Jeongwon Joe and Sander L. Gilman, foreword by Tony Palmer, 1–24. Bloomington, Indiana University Press.

33. Henzel, C. (2004). Wagner und die Filmmusik. Acta Musicologica, Vol. LXXVI/1, 89–115.

34. Hillman, R. (2005). The Great Eclecticism of the Filmmaker Werner Herzog. In Hillman, R. Unsettling Scores: German Film, Music, and Ideology, 136–50. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

35. Hillman, R. (2010). The New German Cinema and Beyond. In Wagner and Cinema, edited by Jeongwon Joe and Sander L. Gilman, foreword by Tony Palmer, 253–73. Bloomington, Indiana University Press.

36. _______. Hommage an Klaus Kinski [Unofficial Website]. Available at: http://www.klaus-kinski. de/9/ (accessed 30.11.2018).

37. Palmer, T. (2010). Foreword. In Wagner and Cinema, edited by Jeongwon Joe and Sander L. Gilman, foreword by Tony Palmer, I‒X. Bloomington, Indiana University Press.

38. Patterson, A. Florian Fricke Interview. In Eurock.com— Music from around the World: Features, Reviews & Podcasts, ed. by Archie Patterson, conducted by Gerhard Augustin. Available at: http://www.eurock.com/features/florian.aspx (accessed 11.11.2018).

39. Paulin, S. D. (2000). Richard Wagner and the Fantasy of Cinematic Unity: The Idea of the Gesamtkunstwerk in the History and Theory of Film Music. In Music and Cinema, ed. by J. Buhler, C. Flinnand, D. Neumeyer, 58–84. Hanover, NH, Wesleyan University Press; London, University Press of New England.

40. Popol Vuh. Unofficial Website. Available at: http://www.popolvuh.nl/d/ (accessed 12.11.2018).

41. Prager, B. (2007). The Cinema of Werner Herzog: Aesthetic Ecstasy and Truth. London, Wallflower.

42. Smart, M. A. (2004). Mimomania: Music and Gesture in Nineteenth-Century Opera. Berkeley, Los Angeles, London, University of California Press. 

43. Syberberg, H. J. (1982). Hitler: A Film from Germany, preface by Susan Sontag, translated by Joachim Neugroschel. New York, Farrar, Straus, Giroux.

44. Trahndorff, K. F. E. (1827). Ästhetik oder Lehre von Weltanschauung und Kunst, erster und zweiter Theil. Berlin, In der Maurerschen Buchhandlung.

45. _______. Werner Herzog. Official Website. Available at: http://www.wernerherzog.com/ (accessed 07.12.2018)